Is AIG the new AAPL?

Tue Mar 19, 2013

Email a friend
  • To include more than one recipient, please seperate each email address with a semi-colon ';', to a maximum of 5 email addresses



A lot of investors will be buying the rumor.


   Dave Dale
By David Dale

A recent Goldman Sachs report shows that AIG has surpassed Apple as the most-favored name among hedge funds. The report showed 117 funds holding the stock, with 80 funds holding it as a top-10 choice. Some in the media are speculating that AIG will soon become the new market darling that everyone starts to pile into, similar to Apple in 2012.

It's easy to see why that could happen. This is a stock that has already shown strong demand in the past year, fully digesting the sales by the US government, including its remaining stake of $7.6B in Q4 alone. Despite the government selling pressure, AIG is up nearly 40% in the past 12 months. With that downward selling pressure behind it, new buyers should lead to healthy appreciation.

As the media begins to spotlight the popularity among hedge funds, will it begin to get the same crowding effect as Apple? Big names such as George Soros and Bruce Berkowitz have previously disclosed large positions, but new attention is being drawn to recent 13-F filings showing growing large positions held by Steve Cohen's SAC Capital Advisors, Leon Cooperman's Omega Advisors and Dan Loeb's Third Point. As AIG outperforms, and these titans enjoy large gains, it will become a stronger lure for buyers fearful of missing out, just as Apple did last year on its upward tear.

The strength of this self-fulfilling cycle should not be understated, as evidenced by Apple's attraction of funds with such varied strategies as dividend value (before Apple had issued any dividend!) to high-yield corporate bond funds. One report showed of Q3 2012 holdings showed that more than 800 hedge funds and mutual funds had Apple among their top ten holdings. Such buying was a large reason for Apple's 75% rise in the first nine months of 2012. While Goldman reported 80 hedge funds included AIG in their top 10, it has a lot more upside potential before it can be called overcrowded.

In addition to the inflow momentum, AIG has the fundamentals to back up the demand. The reported book value is up to $57.87, and a price just below $39 makes for a price-to-book ratio of about 0.65. With many comparable companies trading at about 1.2 times price to book, there seems to be great upside potential. Even if AIG doesn't realize full book value on some of the black-box assets they continue to unwind, a 0.65 book value leaves plenty of room for safety. On an earnings ratio analysis, forward price to earnings is 9.75. This is quite conservative for a company in the early stages of a turnaround.

In its recent expectation-beating quarterly earnings report, the company reported an operating profit of 20 cents a share compared to analyst expectations of an 8 cent loss. In addition, chief executive Benmosche emphasized that AIG remains on track to reduce loss ratios and continue pricing improvements which should drive 2013 results.

Another factor that could add to a buying frenzy is capital return. Continuing to clean up its balance sheet will lead to credit upgrades, allowing AIG to seek dividend approval from the Financial Stability Oversight Council. Benmosche said that "as the year progresses, we will then begin to look at things like could we add a dividend to the stock, and also could we have some kind of a modest stock buyback."

AIG will continue to improving debt coverage ratios and shed non-core assets, such as the sale of its aircraft leasing division. This should open the doors for stock purchases by large dividend funds. As seen with Apple, when a stock begins to fall under multiple investing categories (growth, value, yield, turnaround), demand can multiply. In addition, there are no foreseeable negative catalysts to slow the momentum. As long as this remains the case, a 'buy the rumor' effect can take place on the anticipation of a cash return program in addition to the company's profitability growth.

Momentum has been building as AIG continues to outperform and draw attention from major hedge funds. When this happened with Apple last year, it was quickly overbought and went parabolic. AIG could be the new darling of 2013. Buy ahead of the craze to reap the benefits?

David Dale is an independent market analyst in New York. He was formerly a global markets analyst at RBC Capital Markets. He is long AIG.

ISSN: 2151-1845 / CDC10004H